New York Magazine

Sponsor Directory
Real Estate Showcase - Brooklyn Properties

“Whether you're just curious about real estate or actively looking, check out the Real Estate Showcase, where we feature some of the hottest properties on the market that you need to know about. From the tri-state area and beyond, we do the legwork to present the short list of the best of what’s out there. Click here to find out what we’re spotlighting in this week’s showcase.”

 
 


  See NYC Map
   
  Neighborhood Maps
  Trends & News
  Real Estate Listings
   
  Manhattan
  Chelsea
  East Village
  Gramercy Park
  Greenwich Village
  Hamilton Heights
  Harlem
  Hell's Kitchen
  Lower East Side
  Lower Manhattan
  Midtown East/Sutton Pl.
  Midtown West
  Morningside Heights
  Murray Hill
  NoHo/NoLIta
  SoHo
  TriBeCa
  Upper East Side
  Upper West Side
  Washington Heights
  West Village
   
  Brooklyn
  Boerum Hill
  Brooklyn Hts
  Carroll Gardens
  Clinton Hill
  Cobble Hill
  DUMBO
  Fort Greene
  Greenpoint
  Kennsington
  Park Slope
  Prospect Heights
  Red Hook
  Williamsburg
  Windsor Terrace
   
  Queens
  Astoria and LIC
   
neighborhood profile
Carroll Gardens & Boerum Hill
 
Caroll Gardens' Banania Cafe.
 
The basics: It’s a standard Brooklyn demographic: “Italians who’ve been here for years, Hispanics toward the Gowanus, yuppie families in the really nice brownstones, and twentysomethings renting from the yuppie families,” says resident Adam Green. The average townhouse now sells for over a million, but, Chris Thomas of William B. May points out, “There’s a great deal of variation.”

Boundaries: Carroll Gardens stretches from Douglass to Huntington Streets and from Columbia to Smith Streets. Boerum Hill stretches from Smith Street to Third Avenue and from Atlantic Avenue to Fifth Street.

Borders: Brooklyn Heights and Cobble Hill.

Subway stops: F or G to Carroll St for Carroll Gardens; F or G to Smith St. for Boerum Hill

 

 OUTLOOK

What's new: “The trend has been to take three- and four-family houses and turn them back into one or two-family houses,” says William Ross, president of William S. Ross Real Estate. But there are also a few conversions of industrial spaces, like the 48 rental units in the Lili Rose, a former furniture warehouse at Warren and Smith. Brand-new condos on Degraw Street between Court and Smith, going for around half a million, sold out last year, as did those in the more affordable Martin on Sackett Street—two-bedroom, skyline-view apartments went for $325,000.

Bargain hunting: Try “Carroll Gardens West”—the Red Hook border zone on the far side of the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway. “Sales run 10 to 15 percent below the equivalent amount of space on the other side of the divide,” says Thomas. The Gowanus Canal cleanup has revitalized the southeastern edge of Carroll Gardens—look for “sweet little three-story townhouses that you can still buy for what you’d pay for a two-bedroom condo,” says Thomas. In Boerum Hill, prices drop the closer you get to the projects.

Prediction: Gentrification fueled the price increases of the past several years, but demand is finally cooling—instead of twenty buyers for every property, there are five. Look for sale prices to hold for houses and larger apartments in Carroll Gardens and the prime section of Boerum Hill (closer to Cobble Hill), but to soften for less desirable units. In the long run? “The very last buildable lots have been developed or are being developed,” says Bill Ross. “Within two years, nothing new will be built, and prices should go up a lot.”

— Profile from the March 10, 2003 cover story of New York Magazine

 
 
 
APARTMENT PRICES
TO BUY
2001
2003
Studio/1BR $125K-$300K $150K-$400K
2BR $250K-$525K $350K-$635K
Family Apt. $500K-$675K $500K-$750K
Townhouse $600K-$1.5M $800K-$1.5M
     
TO RENT
2001
2003
Studio/1BR $1,200-$1,800 $1,200-$1,800
2BR $1,800- $2,500 $1,600-$2,500
Family Apt. $2,800-$4,000 $2,400-$3,500
NEIGHBORHOOD BROKERS
Multiple Listing on Our Carroll Gardens' Website
William B. May, 150 Montague St., 718-875-1289
Cobble Heights Realty, 206 Court St., 718-596-3333
Brooklyn Bridge Realty, 211 Court St., 718-625-3700
Harbor View Realty, 179 Atlantic Ave., 718-855-1591
Marilyn Donahue Real Estate, 189 Court St., 718-522-2929

MANAGEMENT CO./PROPERTIES
Renaissance Properties

BEST CITYWIDE BROKER SITES
Corcoran
Halstead
William B. May
Douglas Elliman
COMPARE THIS NEIGHBORHOOD...
How good are the schools? How many violent crimes have taken place lately? How many pothole complaints have been filed? The city of New York has put the data online. Pour over stats and pit one neighborhood against another. Just fill out your address in the "My Neighborhood" box and select the topic of interest — schools, transportation, public safety, and more.
NYC.gov

 RELATED FEATURES
Top 5 New Brooklyn Bars (March 10, 2003)

Best of New York: Brooklyn (March 25, 2002)

Real Estate 2001: Carroll Gardens/Cobble Hill (March 12, 2001)


THE SCENE
Dining
3 Bow Thais: After gaining a loyal Greenpoint following, the owners of Amarin have branched out to Carroll Gardens.
278 Smith St., Between Sackett and Degraw Sts. 718-834-0511

Banania Cafe: This French cafe has helped make Smith Street the trendiest drag in Brooklyn.
241 Smith St.; 718-237-9100

Cafe LULUc: This spinoff of the popular Banania has the trappings of a bistro and the soul of a diner.
214 Smith St., At Baltic St. 718-625-3815

Caserta Vecchia: Look for daily Neapolitan specials like pasta e fagioli and polpettone (otherwise known as meatloaf).
221 Smith St., Between Baltic and Butler Sts.; 718-624-7549 or casertavecchiarestaurant.com

Flying Saucer: Popular local spot for coffee, teas, and comfort food.
494 Atlantic Ave. 718-522-1383

Fragole: Mediterranean restaurant and wine bar with exposed brick interior.
394 Court St. 718-522-7133

The Grocery
: Sub-SoHo prices for inspired dishes on Smith Street's best restaurant.
288 Smith St., Between Union and Sackett Sts. 718-596-3335

More Carroll Gardens Restaurants
More Boerum Hill Restaurants

Nightlife

Boat: The eateries that keep popping up along Smith Street got their first area bar when Boat finally arrived on the scene.
175 Smith St., Between Warren and Wyckoff Sts.; 718-254-0607

Bar Below : If every month brings yet another new bar to Smith Street, this one, beneath an Asian-fusion restaurant, is a keeper.
209 Smith St., At Baltic St. 718-694-2277

Sparky's Ale House: A comfortable neighborhood suds joint for human and canine alike.
481 Court St., At Nelson St. 718-624-5516

Vegas: A spacious bar and lounge with a pool table and jukebox.
135 Smith St., 718-875-8308

More Carroll Bars & Nightclubs
More Boreum Hill Bars & Nightclubs


Shopping
Foundation: This contemporary furniture and home-accessory shop is all about cool colors and clean, simple design.
329 Atlantic Ave., near Smith St. 718-403-9757

Frida's Closet: Namesake Frida Kahlo also inspired the aesthetic of this boutique's beautiful, handcrafted women's clothing.
296 Smith St., at Union St. 718-855-0311

Michelle New York: Contemporary clothing, plus cocktail and bridal attire.
103 Bond St. 718-643-2230

Olive's Very Vintage:
Vintage clothing, accessories and jewelry.
434 Court St., 718-243-9094

Refinery: The store responsible for those ubiquitous 718 T-shirts — and Suzanne Bagdade's wonderful one-of-a-kind totes.
254 Smith St., near Degraw St. 718-643-7861

Try Rae's First: Contemporary men and women's clothing.
430 Court St. 718-935-9573

More Caroll Gardens Stores
More Boreum Hill Stores


RECOMMENDED SITES


Weekly Crime Stats (in PDF format)
Precinct 76: 191 Union St., 718-834-3211

Go Brooklyn:
A weekly guide to entertainment.

BoCoCa - A guide to fashion, furniture, food, cocktails and more in the Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, and Carroll Gardens area.

Brooklyn Yes
- A extensive guide to Brooklyn websites

GoCityKids / Brooklyn - A parent's guide to restaurants, shops, services, and entertainment with kids.

Brooklyn Information and Culture (BRIC)

South Brooklyn Network: Carroll Gardens

South Brooklyn Network: Boerum Hill